Which book did you vote for to win our Mock Caldecott award? Add a comment with the title of the book you chose, and one reason why you voted for it.
147 Comments
Eric
11/13/2017 09:23:47 am
After the fall because he put in details and its not black and wite
Reply
Jacob loomis
11/14/2017 03:17:37 pm
wolf in the snow because the baby wolf is cute and they both care about each other.
Reply
Kaylee Ringleka
11/13/2017 09:24:21 am
I think wolf in the snow because I like how it has the wolves and the person my most favorite part is were the person helps the tiny pup and also were the wolves help the family find her the reason I pick this book is because I love the details of the wolves
Reply
parker
11/13/2017 09:24:32 am
I like this book because its so cool
Reply
levi
11/13/2017 09:24:43 am
my favorite book was wolf in the snow because I liked the wolf because I have a trail on the side of my house.
Reply
Logan
11/13/2017 09:26:26 am
I like wolf in the snow becus a girl helps a wolf
Reply
Brielle
11/13/2017 09:26:36 am
After The Fall I would vote for After The Fall because it has very bright and pretty colors.
Reply
Mallory
11/13/2017 09:27:05 am
I think wolf in the snow is the best because it makes you feel like you are there
Reply
Levi
11/13/2017 09:28:00 am
I voted for after the fall because it is crazy when Hummty Dummty turns into a bird.
Reply
elijah
11/13/2017 09:28:20 am
I like the book afer the fall becose it is cool
Reply
Ashlee
11/13/2017 09:28:49 am
I voted for After The Fall because I like how the illistrater made Humptys wall with roots and leaves on them.
Reply
jayden
11/13/2017 09:28:50 am
after the fall because it has the good ligh
Reply
Lileeanna
11/13/2017 09:28:57 am
I like the book After the fall becase he looks like his paper arplane.and he made his arplane look so cool.
Reply
Madelyn
11/13/2017 09:29:05 am
After The Fall is my favorite because I Iike when he trarns into a bird.
Reply
isaac
11/13/2017 09:29:11 am
I like it hath moor detel and is fone
Reply
xander
11/13/2017 09:29:31 am
I like After The fall because at the end Hupdydumpdy terned into a bird
Reply
ethan
11/13/2017 09:29:40 am
I liked after the fall because it has a lot of detail to it and I like the author because he writes a lot of good books.
Reply
isabella
11/13/2017 09:29:57 am
my most favorite book is the wolf the duck and the mouse because it has more detaile.
Reply
katherine
11/13/2017 09:30:22 am
I like The book of mistakes beuacse wen they made a mistake they trnd it in to something.
Reply
arissa
11/13/2017 09:35:21 am
I like a perfikt day because he put a lot of detals
Reply
Austin
11/13/2017 09:45:08 am
After The Fall. After The Fall I like after the fall because the pictures are really good to me. and also because their is lots of cool birds. and because I like when you take something and then pout it later on in the story and also use it in the beginning of the story to. and like when Humpty Dumpty mad a paper air plane and then turned into the same thing.
Reply
rhys
11/13/2017 10:15:39 am
after the fall I liked it because there was a twisted at the end.
Reply
jr
11/13/2017 10:15:45 am
I like was the prfet day because I love to read ite
Reply
chesney
11/13/2017 10:15:57 am
wolf in the snow because the girl helped the wolf and the wolf helped the girl
Reply
Brycen
11/13/2017 10:16:03 am
all falling because it had a lot
Reply
Gillian
11/13/2017 10:16:09 am
I voted for wolf in the snow,beacause the pictures told the story rather than the words.
Reply
Alaina
11/13/2017 10:16:15 am
I like the wolf in the snow because the wolfs look so realistic and the pictures give me feelings of happiness.
Reply
tucker
11/13/2017 10:16:21 am
after the fall I think that the book I chose shod win because at the end of the book egg tuned in to a bird
Reply
Shelby
11/13/2017 10:16:30 am
I think that the book that should win is After the Fall because I like the pictuers and I like the twist at the end.
Reply
Braedon campbell
11/13/2017 10:16:38 am
I voted for the wolf in the snow because it made me want to have the wolf and I still want that wolf and for all eternity
Reply
Shane
11/13/2017 10:16:56 am
I voted for after the fall because the pictures are detailed and the book kind of teaches a lesson and the book has a powerful ending
Reply
chloe
11/13/2017 10:17:09 am
the wolf the duck and the mouse it was funny
Reply
torstin
11/13/2017 10:17:14 am
I pict aftr the fall becus it techis you to gat back up agan
Reply
presleeigh
11/13/2017 10:17:20 am
I liked the Wolf Duck and the Mouse because I like how the color is shaded and that the wolf doesn't eat anyone!
Reply
Carson
11/13/2017 10:17:31 am
I liked wolf in the snow because the girl helped the wolf and then the wolfs helped the girl.
Reply
Natalie
11/13/2017 10:17:38 am
After the Fall is the best to win because at the end the bird is in betivful and the rot the book the birds are betivful.
Reply
Kensi
11/13/2017 10:18:08 am
After the Fall how humpty dumpty got up again I voted for this book because I really liked when humpty turned into a bird and I like how the wall was decorated the most thing I liked was all the detailes in the pictures.
Reply
Nova
11/13/2017 10:18:33 am
I chose the wolf,duke ,and the mouse because some of it is funing.
Reply
Isabelle
11/13/2017 10:18:57 am
I voted for After The Fall because I liked when Humpty Dumpty turned into a bird.
Reply
jackson
11/13/2017 10:19:07 am
I liked the wolf,duck and mouse I love to hunt
Reply
Alex TASN
11/13/2017 10:19:18 am
I voted for The wolf in the snow, beacause Ilike the girl let the wolf go in the snow.
Reply
Kaylee
11/13/2017 10:19:28 am
I think Wolf in the Snow should win the Caldecott medal for 2018 because the pictures explained the whole story instead of words.
Reply
kendra
11/13/2017 10:19:35 am
I like the wolf the duck and the mouse because it has lots of detail and it is a very good book.
Reply
Kennedy
11/13/2017 10:19:55 am
I voted for The Perfect Day because the author made the pictures look real and used really pretty colors for the flowers and other pictures.
Reply
Mckenna starring
11/13/2017 10:22:39 am
I love the wolf in the snow because it shows love promise and friendship through the whole book
Reply
amyah
11/13/2017 10:22:48 am
I like wolf in the snow because when she helped the wolf she was being nice and being kind to the wolf and I liked when she did that I do that all the time and I think she did a good thing to the wolf and it had more detal in the book.
Reply
olivia
11/13/2017 10:26:14 am
I picked after the fall because I liked the pictures A lot and I really liked the story a lot.Another reason is I thought it was a great book.
Reply
mason
11/14/2017 09:22:20 am
after the fall becus of the grat pichers
Reply
LOGAN
11/14/2017 09:22:38 am
I rily liked After The Fall because I liked the picrs.
Reply
Grant
11/14/2017 09:22:48 am
The wolf in the snow because it has very nice pictures and it shows that you should try to help the envirment and its creatures.
Reply
josette
11/14/2017 09:22:58 am
I chose wolf in the snow because it has no pictures .
Reply
Allyson
11/14/2017 09:23:28 am
I voted for wolf in the snow because the wolves looked so real.
Reply
chance
11/14/2017 09:24:10 am
I voted for after the fall because it is funny and I like funny books.
Reply
shane
11/14/2017 09:24:20 am
I chose wolf in the snow because i like snow and wolfs.
Reply
levi
11/14/2017 09:24:44 am
I chose after the fall because it has good pictures.
Reply
Mckenzi
11/14/2017 09:24:50 am
I picked wolf in the snow because I thought the wolfs were really helpful to the little girl.Another reason is because the wolfs looked very realistic.
Reply
Lauren
11/14/2017 09:25:09 am
I think After The Fall is the best because at the end Humpty turns into a bird .
Reply
waakiin
11/14/2017 09:25:15 am
I voted for the wolf in the snow because the girl helps the little wolf and the little girl falls and the pack helps the girl
Reply
Kaeli
11/14/2017 09:25:21 am
my favorite book was a perfect day because it had pretty pictures,and it was funny.
Reply
Kinley
11/14/2017 09:25:53 am
Wolf in the snow is a good book because it shows kindness and people helping and the wolf helping the kid.
Reply
Liberty
11/14/2017 09:26:06 am
I think that wolf in the snow should win because it has great pictures.And because it was cute when the wolf licks the girl.
Reply
Josi
11/14/2017 09:26:23 am
I like Wolf In The Snow because in the pictures I saw that they were really detailed.
Reply
Ava
11/14/2017 09:26:29 am
I voted for "After The Fall" because there is a lot of detail.
Reply
hudson
11/14/2017 09:26:50 am
I voted after fall because it taut a lesson to him and he turnd into a bird at the end I loved after fall
Reply
Brody
11/14/2017 09:27:13 am
after the fall because its pictures are awesome.
Reply
brayden
11/14/2017 09:28:11 am
I like the book after the fall because I like when his eyes get big.
Reply
jacob.s
11/14/2017 09:29:06 am
I like how humpty dumpty fell off the wall but went back up.
Reply
Mason R.
11/14/2017 09:30:22 am
I liked the wolf and the duck and the mouse because the picturs looked like they were glood and I like the part were the duck and the mouse came out of the wolfs mouth.hahahhahahah that was so funny.
Reply
Giselle
11/14/2017 09:33:14 am
Hi I am Giselle I love wolf in the snow because it's LOVEING!
Reply
Kameron
11/14/2017 09:35:51 am
I voted for the wolf in the snow, because the little girl helped the baby wolf get to it's mother and then the little girl walked home
Reply
J-man (jake)
11/14/2017 10:13:08 am
after the fall because of the color scheme
Reply
Allison
11/14/2017 10:13:41 am
My favorite book is wolf in the Snow.
Reply
brody lechel
11/14/2017 10:13:49 am
after the fall because he turned into a bird
Reply
Zachary
11/14/2017 10:13:54 am
Vote: Wolf in the Snow
Reply
chase
11/14/2017 10:14:05 am
after the fall because he made a paper airplane and it falls on the wall.
Reply
lucas
11/14/2017 10:14:11 am
I voted for the fall because I like it when he turns into a bird.
Reply
Lauren
11/14/2017 10:15:06 am
I really liked after the fall because of how much detail they put in to it.
Reply
Raeanna
11/14/2017 10:15:14 am
after the fall is what I chose. I chose it because it has a lot of details in the pictures and some of the pictures have wonderful colors that match what the author says.
Reply
Caleb
11/14/2017 10:15:40 am
I voted for after the fall because I like it when he climbs the wall and hatches into a bird.
Reply
anna.c
11/14/2017 10:15:57 am
I chose after the fall . I love when he hatches.
Reply
brayden
11/14/2017 10:16:10 am
I voted after the fall because he gets back up and climbs the wall and sees bird again.
Reply
lillian
11/14/2017 10:16:17 am
I chose Wolf in the Snow because the colers are vibrant
Reply
April
11/14/2017 10:16:36 am
after the fall because at the end the egg starts to break with out falling and then turned into a bird and was never scared of hights again.
Reply
My name is Deacon Sidebotham and I go to Dorr Elementary and i am a fourth grader
11/14/2017 10:16:43 am
My favorite book is after fall because it had a good ending
Reply
Ayden
11/14/2017 10:17:03 am
I voted for After The Fall by I can`t remember his name because of best graphics, almost best design, and a good story.
Reply
preston jammes gummo
11/14/2017 10:17:19 am
I voted for wolf in the snow because the wolf is so CUTE!
Reply
maycee
11/14/2017 10:17:54 am
I chose After the fall becose it is like a poem but a book at the same time
Reply
DALTON
11/14/2017 10:18:15 am
Reply
ashlyn
11/14/2017 10:19:24 am
after the fall I think it is a good book if you read it please pick this book it is just great
Reply
Grady
11/14/2017 10:19:45 am
after the fall because the ending was super cool I think how he was a bird that was cool
Reply
Carter
11/14/2017 10:20:36 am
I like after the fall because of all the pictures are great also I like how he faced his fears and did what he belived he could do.and how in the middle of the story he could not reach all the good cereal.and finally he turned into a bird.
Reply
ryan
11/14/2017 10:21:04 am
AFTER THE FALL I like this book because he fall off the wall and he get back on the wall...
Reply
Tim
11/14/2017 10:24:07 am
wolf in the snow because I love the pictures and the wolf the duck and the mouse because I love the pictures on this book to.
Reply
alyssa
11/14/2017 10:24:21 am
the book of mistakes.
Reply
Alyssa K :)
11/14/2017 10:25:40 am
I liked wolf in the snow because the pictures were so cute and I myself love wolfs because there beautiful eyes and they are soft and cuddly also this book reminds me of my old dog Calie and she always was sinking in the snow also this book fits me perfect
Reply
Fynlan
11/15/2017 09:22:19 am
The Wolf the Duck and the Mouse because it had the best pictures.
Reply
riley
11/15/2017 09:22:46 am
I pick after the fall also it was a good book
Reply
trevin berens
11/15/2017 09:22:51 am
I like aftter the fall becose it has the best pichere
Reply
Jake
11/15/2017 09:23:01 am
I voted for after the fall because at the end the egg turns into the bird and he becomes afraid of heights.
Reply
kyle
11/15/2017 09:23:35 am
I think After the fall will win because it is a vary nice book and it has grat picters
Reply
Edin
11/15/2017 09:23:41 am
I am voting for the wolf the duck and the mouse
Reply
mallory
11/15/2017 09:23:56 am
After the Fall. I chose After the Fall because the pichers were cool!
Reply
Ella
11/15/2017 09:24:21 am
I vote for wolf in the snow because I just love the pictures and I love how it takes place outside and I love winter.This is why I vote for this book
Reply
Noland
11/15/2017 09:24:35 am
I like the fall because he never gave up
Reply
Paige
11/15/2017 09:24:53 am
I think that The wolf in the snow is really cool because it has a lot of cool drawings and I do not really like chapter books!
Reply
Jacob
11/15/2017 09:25:19 am
After the Fall.I like After the Fall because it was a silly book.
Reply
Elise
11/15/2017 09:25:25 am
I like after the fall because it has good picires and it is cool
Reply
Lexi
11/15/2017 09:25:34 am
I loved The Wolf,The Duck and The Mouse! The pictures were so amazing!
Reply
brody
11/15/2017 09:26:02 am
I votied for the wolf in the snow it had the best pictrs
Reply
Mylie
11/15/2017 09:26:14 am
I like A Perfect Day because it has butifel picters and the auther youesed awesome colors.
Reply
Raegan Cardosa
11/15/2017 09:26:43 am
I think that the book After The Fall should get the Caldecott medal because it is the book that has the coolest pictures ever and I have always wondered what humpty dumpty did after he fell of the wall and went to the hospital.
Reply
Hannah
11/15/2017 09:26:53 am
The book of Mistakes. I voted for the book of mistakes because I am always making mistakes.
Reply
brayden
11/15/2017 09:27:12 am
the book of mistakes thay put mistakes in the book
Reply
Brooklyn
11/15/2017 09:28:14 am
I voted for after the fall because it tech you a lesson that you don't have to be sced to go on it agan.
Reply
marlee morrison
11/15/2017 09:29:15 am
I think it should be After the fall . cause it has good details.
Reply
Gwenyth
11/15/2017 09:29:16 am
I think that After the Fall should get the Caldecott medal because in the pictures it shows the eggs feelings.
Reply
JOY
11/15/2017 09:31:16 am
I like the wolf in the snow because the pictures are so cute.
Reply
Aaliyah
11/15/2017 09:31:34 am
I picked the wolf in the snow because the wolf is so cute!!!!! And I also thought it was cute because when the parents were trying to find the girl the wolfs were hollowing so the parents would find the girl.
Reply
XAVIOR
11/15/2017 09:33:54 am
I voted for after the fall because it has the best coloring and it is it great .is a kid stoery so you shod vote for it
Reply
Abigail
11/15/2017 10:10:17 am
I voted for After The Fall because I liked the pickturs when he turend into a bird.
Reply
noah
11/15/2017 10:10:44 am
I liked the book of mistakes because it was funny.
Reply
sophia
11/15/2017 10:11:54 am
after the fall because he turned into a bird and it was cool
Reply
michael
11/15/2017 10:12:03 am
I like the wolf the duck and mouse because its funny.
Reply
Taylor
11/15/2017 10:12:15 am
After the fall because he turned into a bird at the end of the book.
Reply
Jet
11/15/2017 10:12:29 am
I voted The Book of Mistakes because the pictures are really inspiring
Reply
Brock
11/15/2017 10:12:36 am
I think the wolf in the snow is the best because it has a lot of details and great pictures.
Reply
sofia
11/15/2017 10:12:55 am
the prfet day because it funny and a good book and I like it so muosh
Reply
ETHYN
11/15/2017 10:13:06 am
I liked after the fall because it was funny
Reply
JOSEPH
11/15/2017 10:13:19 am
I like after the fall because the pictures are good like BANANAS but not as good
Reply
Blake
11/15/2017 10:13:35 am
I chose after the fall because then little kids can read it and learn
Reply
Zakari
11/15/2017 10:13:43 am
I think after the fall because I like the animated pictures and how it was kind of fantasy like and it was just a good book and it shows if you fall down you should get back up and start over.
Reply
Ashton
11/15/2017 10:13:43 am
the wolf an the mouse an the duck because the shotgun part when the mouse an duck fly out the mouth
Reply
logan
11/15/2017 10:13:49 am
I liked after the fall because a egg turns into a giant bird and because it's got a egg making a paper bird then turning into that bird.
Reply
Briana
11/15/2017 10:14:10 am
I like After the Fall. the reason I like that book is because I like how the bird he made with paper is the one he turned out to be at the end.
Reply
Hailey Carter
11/15/2017 10:14:28 am
I like after the fall because it has good paint and it's a good book
Reply
Alexis
11/15/2017 10:14:44 am
I voted for the wolf the duck and the mouse because I think it was funny when the duck and the mouse come flying out of of the wolf and scare the hunter .
Reply
Matthew
11/15/2017 10:15:13 am
I voted for "The Wolf, The Duck, The Mouse" because the wolf has every thing that someone needs in a house and I think it's funny
Reply
Brookelynne
11/15/2017 10:15:43 am
I voted the wolf in the snow because its COOL!!!!!
Reply
Ryleigh
11/15/2017 10:16:10 am
I pit The wolf the duck and the moues because of the cool piachers
Reply
Nicklas
11/15/2017 10:17:28 am
I voted for Wolf In The Snow because you can tell the story in whatever way you want to, It also has great pictures and details
Reply
Lily
11/15/2017 10:19:49 am
I picked the wolf the duck and the mouse because it was funny and it had cool pictures!
Reply
Cheyanne
11/15/2017 10:20:37 am
I like wolf in the snow because of how the girl helps the baby wolf and then the wolfs help the girl
Reply
Hannah Vanvugt Hannink
11/15/2017 10:26:08 am
I voted for wolf in the snow
Reply
Kinley
11/21/2017 09:22:43 am
Im tankfull for our food and that are tanks giving is saved by sahra
Reply
jacob
11/21/2017 09:28:53 am
I,m thankful for my whole family.
Reply
Fynlan
11/22/2017 09:22:56 am
I am thankful for my mom and dad.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Look here for updates about what we're learning and what's happening in the Dorr Elementary Library.
Mr. Jonker
Mr. Jonker is the librarian for Dorr Elemenrary Archives
November 2023
Categories |